Cave Art in Indonesia Dated to 44,000 Years Ago, and the cave art is the earliest known record of ‘storytelling’, researchers say
The artwork found in a limestone cave in 2017, was dated to nearly 44,000 years ago using uranium-series analysis, which they said in the study published on Wednesday in the journal Nature.
It was discovered on the wall of a limestone cave in the south of Sulawesi, Indonesia, and shows wild pigs and dwarf buffalos being pursued – and possibly captured – by human-animal hybrids.
When Maxime Aubert, an archeologist from Griffith University in Australia, looked at the images, he was gob-smacked. “I’d never seen anything like it,” he says.
For many years Aubert and colleagues conduct regular surveys on the limestone-rich region for several years, and it has proven to be a hot spot for some of the earliest cave art in the world.
So far, there are documented more than 200 cave art sites. “We find new sites every year,” Aubert says. “There are hundreds of them; it’s quite amazing.”
In 2014, the same team found hand stencils and animal paintings in a nearby cave that were made at least 40,000 years ago. That finding shattered assumptions that rock art had its origins in Europe.
Last year, Aubert and colleagues also found rock art of a similar style and antiquity on the nearby island of Borneo.
The new hunting scene is in a cave about 20 meters off the ground that was likely never used as a residence because of its location.
Aubert and his colleagues dated the artwork as at least 44,000 years old – the oldest so far – by measuring the amount of uranium and thorium in calcium carbonate nodules deposited on the painting’s surface.
The painting is noteworthy not only for its age but also for what it depicts.
“We have a narrative scene – the first evidence of story-telling,” says Aubert, adding that this represents an important milestone in human cognitive evolution. Hunting scenes in the Lascaux cave in France date to much later – around 17,000 years ago.
“Now we’re more than doubling that,” he says.
The human-animal hybrids – people with animal tails or the heads like birds – are also significant because they indicate that whoever painted them could conceive of something that doesn’t actually exist, says Aubert, and could hint at the beginnings of human spirituality and religion.
The scene also shows what Aubert and his team believe are ropes tied around the neck of a pig. It’s a tantalizing find, which could solve the mystery of who domesticated pigs.
European pigs (Sus scrofa) were domesticated in the Near East around 8000 years ago, but a second domestication event likely took place in Asia. When and where that happened remains a mystery.
It could be that people were already making attempts to tame and domesticate the beast on Sulawesi 44,000 years ago.
Archaeologists are now racing against time and the elements to see what other discoveries the Indonesian caves hold. “[They’re] disappearing at an alarming rate,” says Aubert, “just flaking off and we don’t know exactly what’s happening.”
He and his colleagues are recording the artworks for posterity using 3D laser scanning and taking samples for dating in the handful of sites that have them.